| `We're going down!'
`Charlie Victor Romeo' takes audience into cockpit of doomed
airliners
BY JIM FARBER
THEATER CRITIC
Some of the hottest shows on television are reality-based series
depicting up-close encounters with every conceivable disaster. So
why not create a stage play based on such an event, centered on
cockpit voice recordings of commercial and military aircraft in
distress, at that moment when proper procedure and the certainty of
impending death come face to face?
But if you were to create such a stage show, how could you
maintain the type of journalistic honesty a portrayal of these
scenes would call for without slipping into the trap of morbid
sensationalism, outright bad taste or some perverse form of black
humor?
These were the questions that faced Bob Berger, a former field
engineer and cameraman for CNN, Patrick Daniels and Irving Gregory,
members of Collective Unconscious, a New York-based off-off Broadway
theater collective.
Their solution was “Charlie Victor Romeo,” a theatrical
documentary derived entirely from edited black-box transcripts taken
from six major airline and Air Force emergencies.
Hailed as “a vivid contribution to documentary theater” by The
New York Times , the play became a surprise hit and was extended
again and again at the company's small theater on New York's Lower
East Side.
Now, “Charlie Victor Romeo” is on tour, with performances
Wednesday through July 15 at the Macgowan Little Theatre on the
Westwood campus of UCLA.
Unlike television ratings boosters like “Cops” and “When Animals
Attack,” which are generally condemned for their sensational
approach, “Charlie Victor Romeo” consistently has been praised for
its unsparing truthfulness and dedication to protecting the people
whose lives and deaths it depicts.
The play has been filmed by the U.S. Air Force as a training
video for pilots and has been observed by West Point cadets enrolled
in courses studying engineering psychology and human error.
It also has been seen by relatives of those who died in these and
similar aircraft disasters. And, Berger said, their response has
been consistently one of heartfelt appreciation for the honesty and
integrity of the play's approach.
“My perspective, having worked in electronic news gathering,”
said Berger, speaking from New York, “is that it's everything but
reality. People might watch a show like `Cops' and think that's a
realistic depiction of reality. But reality-based is just that, with
emphasis on `based.' A camera crew inside a cop car can only give
you the reality of a camera crew in a cop car. There's a difference
between objective reality and subjective reality.”
The inspiration for “Charlie Victor Romeo,” Berger said, came
about accidentally during a visit to a Lower East Side bookstore.
While waiting in line to purchase the latest Patrick O'Brian sea
saga, Berger's eye chanced to fall on a book dealing with
investigations of aviation emergencies. He pointed the book out to
his friend and co-member of Collective Unconscious, Irving Gregory,
a former Army intelligence analyst and avid history buff.
“He went off to look at the book,” Berger recalled, “and a few
minutes later, I came up behind him and he was reading the
transcript from an incident. I looked at it, and out of the blue, I
said, `That might be good material for a play.' And he looked at me
and said, `You know, that might be a good idea.' ”
Berger and Irving began to investigate what it would take to make
such a seemingly unlikely subject work on stage.
“We decided that we wanted to make a play that if an airline
captain with 20,000 hours in the seat came and saw it, he would
respect its authenticity,” said Berger, whose CNN assignments
included coverage of the crash of TWA Flight 800 four years ago off
Long Island.
“We realized that if we were going to do something like this,
about events that potentially impact thousands of people, we had to
try to be as ethical as possible. We didn't want people to feel we
were criminals trying to cash in on a media circus. So, once we'd
gotten started, we actually publicized the show to members of the
aviation community, because we wanted them to come.”
The major sources for the play, Berger said, were the transcripts
taken from the cockpit voice recorder, also known as Charlie,
Victor, Romeo, or CVR. These are documents, Berger said, that are in
the public domain.
During the performances of the play, information is projected on
a screen before each incident. For example: United Airlines Flight
232, McDonald Douglas DC-10, Sioux Gateway Airport, Sioux City,
Iowa, July 19, 1989. And at the end, a second slide reveals the
outcome. In the case of Flight 232: 111 fatal, 47 serious, 125
minor, 13 uninjured.
The scenes are based entirely on the length of the CVR recording,
from 20 to 40 minutes.
“The play represents six incidents,” Berger said. “Some are in
their entirety, whether at the beginning the problem had developed
or not. The rate — the time it takes us to do it, versus the time it
actually took to happen — is different, because in reality people
don't talk continually.”
The scenes also involve communication between the tower, the
radar controllers and the service and the maintenance departments of
the airlines, Berger said. And the show is performed by a cast of
eight actors.
“This show has taken an emotional toll on all of us,” Berger
said. But, he added: “We made every effort for it to do that. We're
looking for an accurate representation of the people and their
emotions and their psychological states. Our direction to the actors
was to take the text and try as hard they could to obtain the
psychological understanding of where it's coming from, as if they
were in that situation. Then, to do that with the gravity and
respect it needs.” COMING WHAT: “Charlie Victor Romeo.” WHEN: Opens
at 8 p.m. Wednesday; plays at 8 p.m. Wednesday-Sunday through July
15. WHERE: Macgowan Little Theater, UCLA, Westwood. TICKETS: $35.
INFORMATION: 310-825-2101, or www.performingarts.ucla.edu.
Publish
Date:Friday June 22 |